Nov. 12th, 2016 05:58 pm
alias_sqbr: the symbol pi on a pretty background (I like pi!)
[personal profile] alias_sqbr
This is a really good, thoughtful, humanist science fiction movie. It doesn't turn into horror or action halfway through, it's just about ideas and emotional truth. The heroine isn't badass in any traditional sense, but is still great, and gets treated like a real person instead of a Girl (eg she wears sensible clothes with her hair in a ponytail in situations where that's what any real person would do)

At times it crossed my personal line from "meditative and beautiful" into "ponderously slow" for a minute or two, and I imagine that if "linguist solves alien language problem by thinking about it very seriously" isn't your idea of a good time you'd it boring. But I loved it!

I read the original short story years ago and feel like the movie captures the stuff I loved about it (and I loved it a lot), some aspects didn't translate well to film (eg they do cut out the more technical linguistics) but other parts worked amazingly well. Knowing the plot didn't ruin my enjoyment but Cam LOVED the experience of going in unspoiled and I'm a little sad not to have experienced that.

There's very little "hard science" as in physics etc, Jeremy Renner's physicist character mainly serves as a sidekick. (I think the most sciencey thing he does to progress the plot is solve a fraction) But it's hard scifi in the sense of being about ideas. But also feelings! And a compassion for all people which is something I needed right now. It's also really visually effective, I'm glad we saw it at the cinema.

While ultimately uplifting in a bittersweet sort of way there's some very sad moments and it made me cry.

Content warning about one specific kind of sadness below. This stuff comes up in the first few scenes and I don't spoil anything past that point.

****Content warning, some spoilers****

There's a bunch of stuff to do with death and illness involving a child. I find this kind of thing upsetting and was ok with it (in fact more ok than I was expecting based on my memory of the short story) but your mileage may vary.

Date: 2016-11-12 10:31 am (UTC)
thedeadparrot: (silent sigh)
From: [personal profile] thedeadparrot
I also loved this movie! I am a huge fan of the original short story (and the author of it), and it tries really hard to capture the power and intimacy of the story.

It seems like not going in spoiled also really worked for the friend I went and saw it with, and I'm a little sad I didn't get that experience either.

Date: 2016-11-12 12:01 pm (UTC)
moonvoice: (Default)
From: [personal profile] moonvoice
I also really enjoyed the movie. I was in a very mellow mood, so it never became ponderously slow for me (that could be a YMMV thing obviously). I really enjoyed it though. Not like 'love love love' but 'didn't hate it like I do most science fiction films' (you'd think that was ironic, given I love sci fi in general).

And yeah actually now that you mention it, her character is just kind of wearing sensible clothing all the time. They don't make her like unrealistically 'pretty' and I think a lot of the time the actress was electing to not wear full make up (which they can do - generally it's their call).

I also kind of like that Renner was an unmemorable sidekick. Idk, I feel like normally it's very much the other way around.

October 2017

1 234567
89101112 1314

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Oct. 19th, 2017 08:56 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios